Here is a list of games at which I don’t suck. This list could grow as I am reminded of former video game success stories or as I try games and find out I can handle them pretty well. In other words, this is by no means comprehensive.
Archon (Commodore 64)
Costume Quest (PS3)
Defender (Atari 2600)
Ico (PS2)
Larry Bird vs. Dr J One on One (Atari 7800)
Mario Golf (Game Boy Color)
Maximo (PS2)
Ms. Pac Man (Cocktail Table Arcade)
Portal (XBox360,PS3,PC)
Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando (PS2)
RBI Baseball (NES)
Rock Band 2 (PS3)
Sly Cooper and the Thevius Racoonus (PS2)
SSX Tricky (Gamecube)
Super Puzzle Fighter II Turbo (Arcade + Playstation)
Sword & Poker (iOS)
Tecmo Bowl (NES)
Tetris (Game Boy)
Tommy Lasorda Baseball (Genesis)
Tournament Cyberball (Arcade)
Umjammer Lammy (Playstation)

I suck at all games even Tetris I’m hopeless at.
Platformers are my worst.
Can’t play em at all.
Braid was like taking a big depression pill because I felt awful playing that game.
The only games I’m remotely good at are Racing games and MMO’s because they can be fun without knocking you around.